Are You Managing the Business You Think You Have—or the Business That Actually Exists?

I've spent more than 40 years working with businesses, many of which were facing significant challenges. Some were losing money, others were growing but struggling to keep up, and still others were reasonably successful yet performing well below their potential. Although their circumstances were different, I frequently encountered a common problem: the business its owners and managers believed they were running wasn't necessarily the business that actually existed.

That may sound harsh, but it isn't intended to be. Business owners make hundreds of decisions every month, relying on financial statements, operating reports, conversations with managers, customer feedback, and their own experience. Each of these provides information, but the real question is whether that information creates an accurate understanding of how the business actually operates. In my experience, there is often a considerable gap between what management believes is happening and what is actually taking place.

What You Think You Know

When I first enter a business, I spend considerable time asking questions. How does the company make money? What determines profitability? Where are the operating constraints? How is productivity measured, and what prevents the organization from performing better? These questions usually generate answers, but the answers don't always provide the understanding I'm looking for.

One of my favorite follow-up questions is deceptively simple: How do you know?

It's not unusual to discover that an explanation is based on what someone believes, what they've been told, or how the company has always operated. Those explanations may be correct, but experience has taught me that they deserve to be tested. There is a significant difference between having information and understanding what that information means.

Consider a production report showing how many units were completed yesterday. It may accurately report the output without explaining why production fell short of expectations, how much available capacity went unused, or whether the organization is measuring productivity correctly. Similarly, a financial statement may show increasing revenue while cash continues to deteriorate. A department manager may report that operations are running efficiently, while employees working in that department can readily identify problems that management has never recognized.

In each situation, management has information. What may be missing is the understanding necessary to make better decisions.

An Experience in Manufacturing

Several years ago, I joined an established Southwest Missouri manufacturing company to help improve its operating performance. The organization had considerable potential, but realizing that potential required more than reviewing financial statements and production reports. I needed to understand how work actually moved through the operation, what influenced productivity, and which management practices were helping or restricting performance.

I spent considerable time observing production activities, talking with employees, studying material flow, and examining the decisions that shaped day-to-day operations. I wasn't interested in accepting an explanation simply because it had been repeated for years. I wanted to understand the underlying conditions, including those that might have become so familiar that nobody questioned them anymore.

During my first year, manufacturing productivity improved approximately 41%. The following year, it improved another 26%. Those results weren't achieved through a single remarkable idea or some secret manufacturing technique. They resulted from disciplined observation, a better understanding of the operation, identifying meaningful opportunities for improvement, and ensuring that decisions were carried through to execution.

The experience reinforced a principle I had learned many years earlier: Meaningful improvement begins with understanding, not assumptions.

Leadership by Walking & Talking

One of the practices I've relied upon throughout my career is what I call Leadership by Walking & Talking. I deliberately use that expression rather than the more familiar idea of management by walking around, because there is an important difference between the two.

Walking through a facility, greeting employees, and returning to your office may be good for morale, but it doesn't necessarily improve your understanding of the business. Leadership by Walking & Talking involves purposeful observation and genuine conversations with the people who perform the work. It requires asking questions, listening carefully, and being willing to follow an answer wherever it leads.

Why is material stored in a particular location? What causes equipment to stop? Why does an order require additional handling? What happens when a customer changes a delivery date, and how does that change affect other work already scheduled? These are not complicated questions, but the answers can reveal conditions that have a significant influence on operating performance.

Sometimes those conversations identify an immediate opportunity for improvement. Other times they raise questions requiring additional investigation, and occasionally they reveal something management would rather not hear. That is precisely why the conversations are important.

Employees frequently understand operational problems long before those problems appear in management reports. Unfortunately, many organizations have never developed a reliable way to turn that knowledge into better decisions. The purpose of Leadership by Walking & Talking is not to catch people doing something wrong. It is to understand what is happening, why it is happening, and what the organization can do to improve.

The Danger of Treating Symptoms

Another common problem is the tendency to act before understanding the cause of a problem. Sales decline, so the company hires another salesperson. Production falls behind, so management authorizes overtime. Profitability deteriorates, so expenses are cut. Each of these actions might be appropriate, but each could also make the situation worse if the underlying problem hasn't been identified.

Consider a company experiencing declining sales because customers have lost confidence in its ability to meet delivery commitments. Hiring another salesperson may generate additional orders, but it won't correct the delivery problems that are driving customers away. In fact, additional orders could place even greater pressure on an already struggling operation.

The same principle applies to production. If orders are running behind because work is poorly scheduled or materials aren't available when needed, additional overtime may increase costs without meaningfully increasing output. Management may believe it is addressing a capacity problem when the actual issue is how existing capacity is being managed.

Profitability presents similar challenges. A company may pursue additional revenue without understanding whether that business generates sufficient gross profit to support its operating expenses. Revenue grows, employees work harder, and the organization becomes busier, yet financial performance fails to improve.

These situations illustrate why I resist the temptation to look for a silver bullet. Organizations frequently spend considerable time and money addressing symptoms because those symptoms are visible and demand attention. The underlying causes are often less obvious and require a greater willingness to investigate.

The most obvious problem is not necessarily the problem that needs to be solved first.

Learning to Challenge Your Own Thinking

Business owners and executives accumulate considerable knowledge throughout their careers. That experience is valuable, but it can also create blind spots. We become comfortable with familiar explanations, develop expectations about how people and processes behave, and begin interpreting new information through what we already believe to be true.

Over time, those beliefs can become accepted facts, even when the conditions that originally supported them have changed. A process that worked well five years ago may no longer be appropriate. A management structure that served a smaller company effectively may become an obstacle as the organization grows. A long-standing assumption about customers, costs, or productivity may continue influencing decisions long after it has ceased to be accurate.

One of the most important disciplines I've developed is learning to separate what I know from what I think I know. That distinction is fundamental to the Odyssey Methodology, which follows a continuous cycle:

Notice that deciding comes third, not first. Before making a decision, we need to observe what is happening and develop an understanding of why it is happening. Only then can we make an informed decision, execute it effectively, and learn from the results.

Although this approach sounds straightforward, I've encountered countless examples of organizations moving directly from recognizing a problem to implementing a solution, with little effort devoted to understanding the underlying conditions. The result is often considerable activity without meaningful improvement. People are busy, money is being spent, and management is taking action, but the organization isn't necessarily becoming stronger.

Three Questions Worth Asking

If you own or lead a business, I encourage you to consider three questions that may reveal more about your organization than another management report.

First, what do you believe to be true about your business that you haven't actually verified? It might involve productivity, profitability, customer satisfaction, employee performance, or the reasons your organization struggles to meet its commitments. Consider which explanations have become so familiar that nobody thinks to question them.

Second, how much of your understanding comes from direct observation rather than reports and explanations provided by others? Reports are essential, and capable managers are invaluable, but neither replaces the benefit of seeing how the organization actually operates and listening to the people performing the work.

Third, when was the last time you changed an important decision because you discovered that one of your assumptions was wrong? Effective leaders don't need to have every answer. They do, however, need to recognize when new information challenges their understanding and be willing to adjust their thinking accordingly.

These questions aren't intended to suggest that owners and managers lack knowledge of their businesses. Rather, they recognize that familiarity and understanding are not necessarily the same thing. The closer we are to an organization, the easier it can become to overlook conditions that an objective examination might reveal.

Building a Stronger Business

Over the years, I've learned that improving a business is rarely about discovering one extraordinary solution. More often, it requires developing the discipline to see the organization clearly, understand the factors influencing its performance, make informed decisions, and execute those decisions consistently. It also requires the willingness to learn from the results, challenge previous assumptions, and continue improving.

That discipline can strengthen profitability, improve organizational performance, increase enterprise value, and provide owners with more options for their future. But none of those outcomes can be pursued effectively without first developing an accurate understanding of the business.

The first step toward building a stronger business is understanding the business you actually have—not simply the one you believe you have.

Rob Jones is a turnaround specialist, business broker, author, and creator of the Odyssey Methodology™. Through Odyssey Business Group, he works with business owners and leadership teams to strengthen operating performance, build enterprise value, and create greater owner options. His book, Building a Stronger Business, explores the disciplined thinking and leadership practices behind lasting business improvement.